Vollrath (5314) - 17-3/4" x 12-7/8" Half-Size Sheet Pan - 13 Gauge - Wear-Ever®

Customer Reviews

Date Posted: 4/15/2013 Reviewed By: Kathleen Household Cook Owns this product

"I bought the sheet pan due to a recommendation from Cook's Illustrated. It's definitely worth it, the pan holds it's shape and does not bend. I've used it for roasting vegetables and making a carrot cake!"

Date Posted: 4/8/2013 Reviewed By: Lauri Commercial Kitchen Owner Owns this product

"Arrived as expected the pans are of a heavy gauge. I would recommend a thorough washing to remove manufacturing oils before the first use. "

Date Posted: 3/16/2013 Reviewed By: Janet A Household Cook Owns this product

"this is my third replacement sheet. I have been swapping out my sheets slowly and it is well worth the wait to have such a great product that heats evenly giving consistent cookies every time. It cleans beautifully. I am very happy with the product and its performance."

Date Posted: 3/12/2013 Reviewed By: Shirley from Herndon, VA Household Cook Owns this product

"Made this purchase based on America's test kitchen recommendation, it works as It's description states. Easy to clean (I hand wash + towel dry it immediately), even baking, and no wrapping. I also purchased a C.I.A. wire rack that fits it perfectly. Good buy."

Date Posted: 3/11/2013 Reviewed By: Regina Household Cook Owns this product

"The half-size sheet pan is a wonderful piece of equipment for any home makers kitchen. Being able to buy restaurant grade equipment at a home makers price is amazing. The pans are very sturdy. They cook evenly and the pans have no warping. I will never buy my kitchen equipment anywhere but here."

Date Posted: 2/24/2013 Reviewed By: Janet Household Cook Owns this product

"Thanks to other reviews, I decided to purchase. They seem to be of better quality than those available in my local area, although if I purchased in person - I would have selected ones that were not scratched and discolored. I do wish they would nestle together to save on space. Other than that, I think they are great."

Date Posted: 2/20/2013 Reviewed By: Terri Household Cook Owns this product

"This is a great all purpose baking sheet. The weight is good and the open curved edges allows it to dry without collecting water under the rim. It was recommended by America's Test Kitchen, so I searched to find the exact model. This one has not warped while heating and it is the perfect size for half sheet parchment paper liners. "

Date Posted: 2/15/2013 Reviewed By: Phyllis Household Cook Owns this product

"I would reccomend 17-3/4" x 12-7/8" Half-Size Sheet Pan - 13 Gauge - Wear-Ever for both home and professional use. I use it and find easy to use and clean. I would consider it one of the better items to own for you baking needs. I believe it would be a wise purchase."

Date Posted: 2/6/2013 Reviewed By: Michele Household Cook Owns this product

"Outstanding Product, Heats Evenly, Love Making Cookies on it the bottoms don't Burn. Great Product. Product Cleans Up Very Well, Have Cooked Pork Chops on Them and chicken and they come out evenly cooked and Crisp. I Recommend them to Any Chief and Home cook."

Date Posted: 2/4/2013 Reviewed By: Chris Household Cook Owns this product

"It's really sturdy and durable.It looks good and is just the pan I was looking for. I baked meatballs and chicken breast by using this baking pan and the result was so great. Plus washing pan is super easy. I am willing to buy another size pans."

Date Posted: 2/3/2013 Reviewed By: Jeff Household Cook Owns this product

"Great sheet pan, it is the same one reviewed by cooks illustrated as the best sheet pan of all the ones they tried. Heavy duty, it has not warped at all in the time I have been using it. Would recommend it to anyone who wants a good heavy sheet pan."

Date Posted: 1/24/2013 Reviewed By: Ellyn Household Cook Owns this product

"Finally I have found my dream baking sheets. After years of baking on inferior sheets, I am enjoying these great sheets. From now on I plan to purchase them as gifts for wedding showers and Christmas gifts for my family and friends. Best part is made in the USA."

Date Posted: 1/18/2013 Reviewed By: William Household Cook Owns this product

"Very handy for small cooking assignments and of course when you have small grandchildren who want to help. I like the versatility and handiness of a smaller cookie sheet. Construction is firm and easily grabbed and shifted. Cleaning has been simple and, at least for now, bright and shiny. Nice product."

Date Posted: 1/10/2013 Reviewed By: Christopher Household Cook Owns this product

"These sheet pans are very heavy gauge and rock solid. They will not warp in the oven. I use them for everything from baking cookies to roasting bones. Add a "V" rack and it works great for roasting poultry and beef roasts. Add a cooling rack and it works great for air "frying" French fries and other root veggies. This is a very useful and versatile pan. "

Date Posted: 1/10/2013 Reviewed By: Nancy Household Cook Owns this product

"Love the pans! I would recommend to anyone who appreciates having pretty top notch equipment in their kitchens. Good sheet pans make it look like you are serious, and you are when you get great results, even baking, plenty of room to spread those veggies out and not have them spilling all over your oven."

Date Posted: 1/10/2013 Reviewed By: Rachel Household Cook Owns this product

"I got pans for myself and as a gift for my father after seeing the stellar review by Cook's Illustrated. These pans don't disappoint! Clean easily, they're right-sized, right-priced, they won't warp, and they're properly weighted. I would definitely recommend to casual or professional users."

Date Posted: 1/10/2013 Reviewed By: Diane Household Cook Owns this product

"I love these half size sheet pans. They made wonderful Christmas cookies. This is the first time all my cookies were evenly baked. They were extremely easy to clean. I only purchased two half size sheet pans and plan to purchase more for next year. Look forward to doing more baking."

Date Posted: 12/28/2012 Reviewed By: Brian Household Cook Owns this product

"Very well constructed with sturdy rolled lip. Heavy gauge aluminum means this doesn't warp or bend while loaded up with food. Excellent size to fit in a home oven with plenty of room for 16 cookies or lots of roasted veggies. Good finish on the rolled edges."

Date Posted: 12/28/2012 Reviewed By: Kathleen Household Cook Owns this product

"Pans are not too heavy and easy to handle yet very sturdy. Nest well for storage. No rounded edges to catch water and rust and easy to clean. Distribute heat evenly for baking and roasting. I am very satisfied with purchase and would purchase again."

Date Posted: 12/27/2012 Reviewed By: Maureen Household Cook Owns this product

"I was very pleased with the pans. They baked my cookies evenly. A small amount of warping occurred in the middle of the plans, but it did not affect my baking. I have tried many types of pans over the years, and I definitely like these the best and would recommend them."

Date Posted: 12/26/2012 Reviewed By: Jonathan Household Cook Owns this product

"These are great sheet pans to use for cookies. I don't notice any warping of the pans when they are being used for cookies. I would recommend them, after reading about them in Cook's Illustrated! I use them with parchment paper, and my baking products have come out wonderfully each time I've used them."

Date Posted: 12/16/2012 Reviewed By: Rita Household Cook Owns this product

"These are the best cookie sheets that I have ever used. My cookies and nut rolls came out perfectly cooked and nicely brown on the bottom. It did take a little adjustment on the cooking time-more time was needed than recipes suggested. They are also very easy to clean."

Date Posted: 12/6/2012 Reviewed By: John Household Cook Owns this product

"A very sturdy, I would say commercial grade, sheet pan. Very well made and a pleasure to use. This is the sheet pan recommended by Cooks Illustrated and lives up to its billing. Do not be fooled and purchase a virtually identical pan that is not made of the 13 gauge material."

Date Posted: 12/6/2012 Reviewed By: Javier Household Cook Owns this product

"A very good, sturdy pan. It is made of heavy-gauge aluminum but it is still lightweight and it has yet to warp in the oven. So far it has "lived-up" to expectations, especially when broiling food and the pan is very close to the flame (gas oven). Hand washing is recommended, for they will discolor very badly if washed in the dishwasher. I learned this the hard way with the quarter size sheet pans. I wish I had known about this the first time. Hand washing them is however very easy."

Date Posted: 11/30/2012 Reviewed By: Avery Other Owns this product

"This is an excellent cookie sheet! The gauge is heavy and so far there has been no warping. However, the undersides of the rolled edges are razor sharp and I would not have ordered this product had I really known that. Each edge of the 13 gauge metal is extremely dangerous. When you take the sheet out of the oven you will have to have on an oven mitt, otherwise, all touching will be barehanded. "

Date Posted: 11/17/2012 Reviewed By: John Household Cook Owns this product

"While I am a home cook, I have cooked professionally. I found these after their being recommended by one the of Food Network chef's in one of his books. These are solid aluminum which is FAR superior to coated aluminum pans sold by other vendors. Coated aluminum pans are not dishwasher safe, the coating comes off; but, these are which was a huge plus for me. Cooking with them is very easy. They heat evenly, clean easily, do not warp when heated, and as mentioned above, are absolutely dishwasher safe. And shipping is VERY fast. "

Date Posted: 8/18/2012 Reviewed By: Charlene Household Cook Owns this product

"I wanted the best pans in order to make my crackers and new recipes. These pans fit perfect in the oven so I can make a couple batches of crackers at a time. They don't stick and they cook very evenly. I have another set I purchased last year so now I will be able to keep on baking!!!! "

Date Posted: 7/11/2012 Reviewed By: Doris Household Cook Owns this product

"Excellent quality. This pan was recommended by Cooks Illustrated Magazine, and at my first use of this pan it proved to be excellent. I would definitely recommend this pan to others, and I will probably order another one for myself and maybe as a gift"

Date Posted: 2/17/2012 Reviewed By: Illah Household Cook Owns this product

"These pans are beautiful. The heavy weight of the pans allow the cookies or biscuits to brown beautifully on the bottom. The are the right size to fit a cooling rack inside to drain drippings or frosting. I have been married 61 years and these pans are a wonderful addition to my kitchen after all this time!!"

Date Posted: 1/16/2012 Reviewed By: Marie Household Cook Owns this product

"II have received 2 of these trays since Christmas. The 1st was badly warped and has deep scratches. The replacement was slightly warped and had a few deep scratches. My original Wearever #5314 is over 10 years old. It isn't warped and has only surface scratches. I am very disappointed and will not reorder. "

Date Posted: 1/13/2012 Reviewed By: Chris Household Cook Owns this product

"Great product with a very high quality. These are significantly better then those poorly constructed pans found in stores. These are made with very high quality materials and hold up quite well. They don't bend, leak or rust. I would not put in dishwasher. Use parchment paper for great results. "

Date Posted: 1/5/2012 Reviewed By: Gloria from Sun Lakes, AZ Household Cook Owns this product

"Does not warp and conveys even heat. It is a nice weight while not being too heavy. We use it often and will probably buy 1-2 more sheets in the near future. It is one of those basic cooking supplies that everyone needs and looks like it will last a very long time."

Date Posted: 1/3/2012 Reviewed By: Michelle Household Cook Owns this product

"I love this pan. It's a great size for feeding 2 or 4 people. I would recommend it to anyone. I fit 12 pigs in blaket on one sheet and its great for fries too. It cleans up nicely without scrubbing. I also bought 2 for gifts. Thanks for a quality item that I can recommend to others. "

Date Posted: 12/13/2011 Reviewed By: Carol Household Cook Owns this product

"Easy, easy cleanup. I use this pan to roast vegetables and they carmalize beautifully. The weight means it doesn't warp in a hot oven. It's an easy pan to deglaze. This pan will outlast all the rest. It's also a very versatile size. I recently purchased a cooling rack to fit. "

Date Posted: 12/12/2011 Reviewed By: Renee Household Cook Owns this product

"We purchased this based on a review from Cooksilustrated.com. It is by far the best quality cookie sheet we have ever owned. We have used it for cookies, breads and have roasted vegetables on it and everything has turned out fantastic. It has been easy to clean as well. We plan on purchasing another one."

Date Posted: 12/12/2011 Reviewed By: Matt Household Cook Owns this product

"This sheet pan is well constructed, handling a very hot oven (550 degrees) without warping. The item also was easy to clean, so it still looks like new after the first couple of uses. I was rather disappointed the item came with a large scratch on the surface."

Date Posted: 12/12/2011 Reviewed By: Diane Household Cook Owns this product

"LOVE these pans that Cooks Illustrated rated as the best. VERY happy with the product AND your good service and fast delivery!! These pans clean up so easily and are a very nice and sturdy weight..I use them every day. I highly recommend this pan!"

Date Posted: 11/30/2011 Reviewed By: Deborah Household Cook Owns this product

"This pan is an excellent purchase. The solid construction makes it able to handle weight without bending, heat without warping, and to conduct heat extremely evenly. Gives me perfect cookies every time, and lined with parchment, allows me to easily slip the cookies onto a cooling rack. "

Date Posted: 9/15/2011 Reviewed By: Deborah from Libby, MT Household Cook Owns this product

"Great multi-use pan. I use it for cookies, tarts, roasting vegetables and anything else where a rimmed pam is desireable. It is sturdy and cleans easily. The flat design stores within a minimal space. I definitely recommend this pan for multiple reasons."

Date Posted: 4/28/2011 Reviewed By: Laurel Household Cook Owns this product

"Very nice sheet pan. It is heavy duty and just what I wanted. There has been a little warp but does not effect usage. There was a review about not liking the edges but I didn't find them sharp. Cleans up easily. When moving from oven to counter there is no bend."

Date Posted: 4/14/2011 Reviewed By: Ann Household Cook Owns this product

"These pans are the best pans I have ever owned. They have a great weight to them and they do not warp in a high heat oven. They are extremely sturdy. I love love love them! I did have a problem with my pans when they arrived. They were completely stuck together! I could not get them apart! I was afraid to use anything to pry them apart for fear of ruining them. I sent an email to FSW and they sent me 2 new ones within a few days. Beautiful! Fast delivery, great customer service! I HIGHLY recommend these pans and FSW!"

Date Posted: 4/1/2011 Reviewed By: Sue Household Cook Owns this product

"These are simply the best half sheet pans! After years of buying and re-buying 'consumer store' brand sheet pans ("cookie sheets"), after they warped, I finally read reviews before this purchase. These #5314's are probably the last sheets I'll ever need, and I can foresee passing them down to my kids! They are VERY heavy duty, hold and distribute heat excellently (much, much better than so-called air sheets), and clean up well. I made the best batch of cookies I have ever made with these. "

Date Posted: 3/19/2011 Reviewed By: Jim Household Cook Owns this product

"This is like the ones we used in restaurants 30 years ago. No more cheap discount store cookie sheets for me. This one will last for years"

Date Posted: 3/19/2011 Reviewed By: Betty Household Cook Owns this product

"Strong fantastic baking sheet! This sheet pan bakes accurately and is an easy clean up. Perfect size for matching sized racks."

Date Posted: 3/10/2011 Reviewed By: Matt Household Cook Owns this product

"I purchased this pan after numerous other makes and models proved inconsistent, unreliable and downright disappointing. I am pleased to say that this pan has exceeded all of my expectations. I use it for breads, roasts, sheet cakes, you name it. It holds up well in very high temperatures and shows no indication of warping. Conveniently, it fits a Silpat perfectly and browns baked goods at the correct rate. I would highly recommend this product. "

Date Posted: 2/4/2011 Reviewed By: Bette i Household Cook Does not own this product

"Does not buckle when used in very hot oven. Bakes evenly. Recommend it highly."

Date Posted: 1/28/2011 Reviewed By: Teresa Household Cook Does not own this product

"Great Quaility. Received in a timely maner. Very satisfied."

Date Posted: 1/20/2011 Reviewed By: Richard Household Cook Does not own this product

"HEAVY weight pan recommended by Cooks Illustrated. And boy were they right. This "gift" for my daughter in law was tested by us over and over. Forgot to spray "pam" or use parchment paper when baking cho. chip cookies, but fortunately we got them off they pan as soon as they came out of the oven. (Sooner than we normally would, but they didn't stick!) In any event, ALL our different types of cookies baked up beautifully. The correct amount of browning around the edges, crispy when they should be crispy. Soft baked when they should be soft baked. Almost like the pan KNOWS how to cook the cookies."

Date Posted: 1/14/2011 Reviewed By: Robert Household Cook Owns this product

"I read a review of this product in America's Test Kitchen, which rated it highly. I have been impressed by the even cooking characteristics as well as the fact that as a result of the pan being sturdier it does not warp during cooking or after. All in all an excellent product."

Date Posted: 1/14/2011 Reviewed By: Errol Household Cook Owns this product

"Wish we'd bought these pans years ago. They're strong, they don't warp, and despite not having a specifically "no-stick" surface - which would invariably get mangled in our household. - they readily turn loose of baked goods from pizzas to cookies with only minimal coaxing. "

Date Posted: 1/10/2011 Reviewed By: Carol Household Cook Owns this product

"Just need to be mindful of the edges otherwise its great. Even cooking with no warping in the oven. Enjoyed making wonderful Christmas cookies this year."

Date Posted: 1/8/2011 Reviewed By: Rani Household Cook Owns this product

"This is an excellent sheet pan. It was recommended by Cooks Illustrated and they know their kitchen gear. I am very happy with the pans I ordered. They do not warp when I bake and food comes off cleanly. Great product!"

Date Posted: 1/8/2011 Reviewed By: Gail Household Cook Owns this product

"I bought this because it was recommended by America's Test Kitchen. It is a great pan and it cleans up beautifully. "

Date Posted: 1/7/2011 Reviewed By: Jane L. Household Cook Owns this product

"Good, solid sheet pan. Does not flex with heat or when handling it with a heavier load of food. Comfortable edges for gripping."

Date Posted: 1/6/2011 Reviewed By: Joan Household Cook Owns this product

"I initially bought product to bake cookies. The cookies were perfectly done. The product is beautiful. I love the metal, and the way it cooks the food product. I'm very happy that I bought this pan."

Date Posted: 1/5/2011 Reviewed By: Maryanne Household Cook Owns this product

"Awesome pans, they stack great to take minimal room in my tight kitchen. They bake cookies to perfection and act like non-stick pans even though they're not. I bought 4 and intend to buy 4 more!"

Date Posted: 1/3/2011 Reviewed By: James Household Cook Owns this product

"Very sturdy construction. Nicely rolled edge is easy to grip and provides good rigidity to pan. Others I've looked at are flimsy by comparison. A very high quality pan, especially for the price."

Date Posted: 1/3/2011 Reviewed By: Denis Household Cook Does not own this product

"Sheet pans are excellent, good solid pans. Used with wire rack to slow cook turkey which turned out very well. "

Date Posted: 1/3/2011 Reviewed By: Persis Household Cook Owns this product

"Quality sheet pan used for holiday chex mix, just purchased. I will use it for veggies and focaccia bread . It warped a little the first time I used it from oven to top of range 250 didn't notice it after that. It is discoloring a little but that will not bother the baking use. It was recommended by cook's illustrated and they do a lot of baking and testing should outlast all the others."

Date Posted: 1/3/2011 Reviewed By: Katherine Household Cook Owns this product

"Excellent sheets that seem very strong and easy to clean. Food cooks evenly and properly on these sheets. Easy to clean."

Date Posted: 1/3/2011 Reviewed By: John A. Household Cook Owns this product

"Excellent service and great product"

Date Posted: 1/1/2011 Reviewed By: Susan Household Cook Owns this product

"These pans are such a pleasure to use. I bake with them and I have great results. Cook's Illustrated was right about these pans."

Date Posted: 12/31/2010 Reviewed By: Richard from Oakland, CA Household Cook Owns this product

"This pan is sturdy and doesn't buckle under broiler heat. Standard cooking racks fit perfectly in the pan. It's easy to clean and dry because the rolled edges do not trap water. In short, on all counts this is an excellent half-sheet pan."

Date Posted: 12/31/2010 Reviewed By: Johnson Household Cook Owns this product

"The pan came as expected - sturdy and looks ready for use for a long time to come. I got the recommendation from Cooks Illustrated and think this is a good buy."

Date Posted: 12/29/2010 Reviewed By: Myra Household Cook Owns this product

"COOK'S ILLUSTRATED rated this pan as superior in quality so I HAD to have one...C I is my cooking BIBLE! I knew it was a winner the first time I used it.....not even a wink of warping and my SILPAT sheets fit perfectly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Date Posted: 12/29/2010 Reviewed By: Sheila Household Cook Owns this product

"I was looking for a pan that didn't warp during baking, as this fit the bill perfectly."

Date Posted: 12/28/2010 Reviewed By: David Household Cook Owns this product

"I like the pans, they are very durable"

Date Posted: 12/7/2010 Reviewed By: Frances Household Cook Owns this product

"Very sturdy; doesn't warp when used in high heat cooking. Edges are a little too sharp.... use caution when washing by hand."

Date Posted: 11/6/2010 Reviewed By: Gail Household Cook Owns this product

"The pans are the perfect size and are sturdy and of good weight. Cleans up very nicely. The light colored surface allows for even heating and browning"

Date Posted: 11/6/2010 Reviewed By: Ilse Household Cook Owns this product

"I've been looking for a good baking sheet and this came highly recommended by Cook's Illustrated Test Kitchen. After searching the web, I found you. Thank you for having the exact item at a reasonable price."

Date Posted: 10/31/2010 Reviewed By: Robert Household Cook Owns this product

"These sheet pans came highly recommended and appear to fullfil their advanced billing. They are very stable through extreme temperature swings and essentially non-stick despite lack of a coating. They look like they will last forever."

Date Posted: 10/1/2010 Reviewed By: Kathy from Arvada, CO Household Cook Owns this product

"I use these all the time for all kinds of cooking and they do not warp in high heat and are all around great."

Date Posted: 9/19/2010 Reviewed By: Laura Household Cook Owns this product

"Very heavy material. Sturdy. Comes out great in the dishwasher. Would definately recommend to others. "

Date Posted: 8/30/2010 Reviewed By: John Household Cook Owns this product

"nice pan, very sharp edges"

Date Posted: 4/4/2010 Reviewed By: Marilyn Household Cook Owns this product

"Wow...this is a great product. I am now roasting vegetables 3-4 times a week. The pans are durable and don't warp, even under high (450-500 degree) temperatures. Easy to clean. "

Date Posted: 3/22/2010 Reviewed By: Roxanne Household Cook Owns this product

"I bought the 1/2 size sheet pan after reading a review from "Cook's illustrated". Mainly I was looking for a sheet pan that would not warp or buckle in the oven. I'm not too shot in the fanny with this one. Altho it is 18 gauge, it warped the first time I used it. Will continue my quest."

Date Posted: 3/20/2010 Reviewed By: David R Household Cook Owns this product

"Recommended by Cooks Illustrated. What more can you ask for? Nice heavy gauge pans. I bought 2 along with the CIA cooling racks that were also recommended by Cooks Illustrated. They work together perfectly. "

Date Posted: 3/6/2010 Reviewed By: Amy Household Cook Owns this product

"This is a sturdy pan, does not warp when heated."

Date Posted: 2/19/2010 Reviewed By: Wendy Household Cook Owns this product

"I was pleased with the quality of the half sheet baking pans I ordered. When I used them, with a rack to bake bacon, I found them to be sturdy, and easy to clean. I purchased these based on a review in Cooks Illustrated, as I believe this organization provides sound advice for kitchen equipment. The pans were exactly as described in the magazine review. "

Date Posted: 2/16/2010 Reviewed By: Denise Household Cook Owns this product

"Great pan, cleans up easy, no warping."

Date Posted: 2/11/2010 Reviewed By: Wendy Household Cook Owns this product

"Nice and heavy pans, but edges would be better if they were rolled; the edges feel a bit rough and it seems like I could cut my hand on them (although I have not yet done so). The finish discolored the first time I washed them in the dishwasher. I am not sure if I should not have put them in, but anyway the pans still work fine."

Date Posted: 1/27/2010 Reviewed By: Richard Household Cook Owns this product

"The sheet pans are heavy weight and resistant to warping. They feel secure when loaded, moving into and out of the oven. They clean-up easily."

Date Posted: 1/18/2010 Reviewed By: Maria Household Cook Owns this product

"The product is excellent. I read a review on America's Test Kitchen and they were right. It made excellent cookies and rolls."

Date Posted: 1/17/2010 Reviewed By: Robert Household Cook Owns this product

"This is not your flimsy homeowners pan. This is a heavy duty pan. Great size, easy clean"

Date Posted: 1/14/2010 Reviewed By: John Household Cook Owns this product

"I did a ton of research after seeing this product on ATK. Don't be fooled, there are many copies but the 5314 model is the best half sheet pan out there. The weight provides an even cooking surface. I bought two and don"t regret it."

Date Posted: 1/9/2010 Reviewed By: Cathy Household Cook Owns this product

"Very sturdy pans. No warping even at 500 degrees. Clean-up is easy. Now I need a slightly wider oven so that my two pans can sit side by side!"

Date Posted: 1/8/2010 Reviewed By: Adam Household Cook Owns this product

"These pans are well constructed and even heating. Their thick gauge ensures a very rigid pan that does not warp and maintains a perfect heat. Best sheet pan out there."

Date Posted: 1/8/2010 Reviewed By: John Household Cook Owns this product

"I purchased these mostly for baking cookies. They have performed perfectly with all types of cookies; especially hard use this Christmas. I gave one to my sister who also said it worked extremely well."

Date Posted: 1/4/2010 Reviewed By: Michael Household Cook Owns this product

"They are very sturdy pans. I do a lot of baking during the holidays; pies and cookies. I bought these because I've had bad luck with pans warping while cooking pies and spilling all over the pan and oven. Plus they were recommended on the PBS cooking show "Cook's Country". These pans surpassed all expectations. "

Date Posted: 1/3/2010 Reviewed By: Tara Household Cook Owns this product

"Great product at a wonderful price. It is a really solid pan, with very smooth rounded edges. It cleans up like a breeze and cooks everything amazingly! Cookies, jelly rolls, even cakes cook up great with this pan."

Date Posted: 12/31/2009 Reviewed By: Minnie Household Cook Owns this product

"Professional quality, but it's half-sheet size makes it perfect for use in domestic ovens. It is also easy to store."

Date Posted: 12/31/2009 Reviewed By: Steve Household Cook Owns this product

"These pans are far superior to any I've ever used. Most importantly they don't buckle under high heat, and they are very thick and cook evenly."

Date Posted: 12/28/2009 Reviewed By: Gail Household Cook Owns this product

"I purchased two sheet pans as a gift for my daughter. She liked them so much I purchased one for myself!"

Date Posted: 12/5/2009 Reviewed By: Deborah Household Cook Owns this product

"Good heavy duty commercial style baking sheet. However, will warp if used under broiler for extended time."

Date Posted: 12/3/2009 Reviewed By: Tracy Household Cook Owns this product

"Perfect pan for daily use because it can take a beating. Might be a little heavy for some users but you get used to it. Cooling racks fit perfectly inside with no shifting. "

Date Posted: 11/26/2009 Reviewed By: Steve Household Cook Owns this product

"This is a great pan. I really love it."

Date Posted: 10/17/2009 Reviewed By: Jennifer Household Cook Owns this product

"I bought two of these pans after hearing about them on America's Test Kitchen, let me tell you they are wonderful. My cookies and pastries are delicious like you buy at the bakery. Everything cooks evenly and is no longer crispy! They are easy to wash and surpisingly nothing sticks. Great pan I am definately buying more for Christmas cookies."

Date Posted: 10/9/2009 Reviewed By: Les Household Cook Owns this product

"This product was rated the best baking sheet by America's Test Kitchen, and they tested it thisaway and thataway. It's a very sturdy, thick metal sheet that won't warp in the oven. Furthermore it's got a useful size advantage over some of our old baking sheets. It's about an inch longer and an inch wider. Still fits in the oven, of course, but that extra inch makes for, gee, about 24 additional square inches of surface? Handy."

Date Posted: 10/3/2009 Reviewed By: Anne Household Cook Owns this product

"Nice, heavy duty pans that don't warp under higher temperatures in the oven. Great for cookies, broiling a side of salmon, or baking bread."

Date Posted: 8/23/2009 Reviewed By: Reuben Household Cook Owns this product

"This baking pan has worked very well for us. We use it often and it has not warped even at high temperature pizza oven temperatures. We use it mostly for cookies and tarts. Cleans well and has held up very well so far. We own two."

Date Posted: 8/14/2009 Reviewed By: Angelos Household Cook Owns this product

"Nice thick pans that cook evenly. I like them a lot."

Date Posted: 7/23/2009 Reviewed By: Mary Household Cook Owns this product

"Really great pans, I looked everywhere for something comparable and finally saw the review on America's Test Kitchens. The price is unbeatable, the delivery price was quite acceptable and the delivery was right on time. You'll love these pans!!! They are fabulous!"

Date Posted: 7/6/2009 Reviewed By: Fred Household Cook Owns this product

"The pan is made from heavy gauge metal and is flat and robust. My only issue with it is the rolled edge isn't fully rolled under so there's a bit of an edge on the underside of it that is annoying."

Date Posted: 6/25/2009 Reviewed By: Trevor Household Cook Owns this product

"Purchased these baking sheets because of the American Test Kitchen review. The are great. Purchsed the cooling racks as well. Will be using these for both baking and general kitchen use. Have not heated them in the 500 degree oven yet, but that is not really why I purchased them. Excellent for baking, and keeping food warm in the oven. "

Date Posted: 5/21/2009 Reviewed By: Susie Household Cook Owns this product

"These were recommended by Cook's Illustrated, which does extensive tests on equipment, and they really live up to the hype! Excellent sheet pans!"

Date Posted: 5/14/2009 Reviewed By: Kim Household Cook Owns this product

"Heavy construction, easy to clean and no warping, all I needed. The pans were quickly delivered and well packaged, I have no problems ordering from FSW for special items."

Date Posted: 4/9/2009 Reviewed By: Joyce from Blue Earth, MN Household Cook Owns this product

"The cookie sheets bake even and cookies turn out great. Also made bars in them and they also were very good. The pans are easy to clean. They are heavy and work great. Going to buy more for Christmas presents."

Date Posted: 4/4/2009 Reviewed By: Stephen from Walnut Creek, CA Household Cook Owns this product

"These trays are nice and sturdy. I am pleased with them and got them under the recommendation of Cook's Illustrated. Although some people have suggested they are not as good as was recommended by them, I think they are the perfect cooking sheets for home use. "

Date Posted: 3/28/2009 Reviewed By: Kenneth from Morristown, NJ Household Cook Owns this product

"This is a substanital pan that will not warp or pop in the oven."

Date Posted: 2/27/2009 Reviewed By: Tracy from Rochester, NY Household Cook Owns this product

"This pan is very versatile. I have used the pan for pizza, cookies, chicken, etc. I love it. Easy to clean."

Date Posted: 2/21/2009 Reviewed By: Lynette from Jamaica, NY Household Cook Owns this product

"Very sturdy, washes easily and no warping so far at 450 degrees. Stupendous!"